Contractors cite IR35 lack of clarity

A new survey of more than 3,300 contractors has flagged continuing confusion, frustration and lack of preparation for the impending introduction of Off-Payroll legislation to the private sector this April.

The ‘IR35 Road Ahead Survey’ conducted by IR35 Shield in December also points to a surge in tax avoidance schemes, operating “under the guise of umbrellas and payroll companies”, the survey narrative says, leaving 74% of contractors unable to distinguish between a compliant umbrella company and a tax avoidance scheme.

Illustrating the potential for compliance fraud, the survey results show that 60% of respondents regularly or occasionally receive marketing from schemes offering take-home pay of circa 85% and only 43% of respondents reporting that they are confident they could perform their own tax calculation to make sure it is correct.

“Government efforts to tackle these schemes clearly aren’t working,” the results narrative said. For instance, as of April 2020, agencies are required to provide workers with a Key Information Document (KID), designed to offer transparency around aspects such as pay. However, 86% of respondents said their agency had not provided them with a KID and 67% weren’t aware of what a KID is.

IR35 Shield CEO Dave Chaplin said: “Following the April 2017 public sector implementation, we also saw a plethora of third-party payroll companies enter the unregulated umbrella market, which resulted in 6,000 contractors unwittingly becoming involved in dodgy tax avoidance or evasion schemes.”

While 62% of respondents said they had been invited to work via an umbrella company, 61% claimed they would not respond to an advert for an ‘umbrella only’ contract. Only 8% said they would be happy to use one. 

Thirty-six per cent of respondents have been invited to work via their agency’s payroll, but 44% of respondents said they would never work via either agency payroll or umbrella. 

Other survey results include:

  • 52% of in-work contractors are yet to be assessed
  • 23% of in-work contractors say their client has imposed a blanket ban on the use of limited companies
  • 65% of contractors will avoid ‘inside IR35’ contracts
  • 69% will increase their rate for on-payroll assignments
  • 72% will quote separate rates for contracts depending on IR35 status
  • 75% believe HMRC’s controversial Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool is inaccurate, and only 3% trust the tool.

• Comment below on this story. Or let us know what you think by emailing us at [email protected] or tweet us to tell us your thoughts or share this story with a friend.


This week’s appointments include: Focus Management Consultants, Four Recruitment, Harvey Nash Group, Pedersen & Partners, Remote, Timewise

People 12 January 2021

The ultimate stay-at-home role: slipper testers required

Snagging a job that keeps your feet nice and cosy is one thing – but finding one that can promise that and be done from home is quite another.

Lighter Side 11 January 2021

REC lobbying wins injections for frontline agency staff

Frontline agency staff must be included in vaccination plans of NHS Trusts in England from Monday, following instructions from NHS England.

8 January 2021

Marketing group IPG selects Worksome to manage freelance talent

Online recruitment and freelance platform Worksome has been selected by the Interpublic Group (IPG) to manage its freelance requirement from the Worksome platform.

Contracts 8 January 2021