Recruitment industry criticises NI increases for social care reforms

The announcement yesterday [7 September] of National Insurance (NI) and dividend tax increases to cover NHS and social care reforms has been roundly criticised by representatives of the recruitment sector and umbrella workers.

From April 2022, NI will increase by 1.25%. At the same time, the dividend rate will be increased to 8.75% and 33.75% on both the employed and self-employed, whose income falls above the Primary Threshold/Lower Profits Limit of £9,569.

“We all agree that social care needs more funding, but increasing labour taxes as we try to recover from the pandemic is not the fairest way to do it,” said Neil Carberry, CEO of the Recruitment & Employment Confederation (REC). For instance, he said, the 1.25% rise in NI “is the wrong choice”. The accompanying rise in taxes on dividends “will hit small limited company directors, who were denied any support during the pandemic”, he added. 

Tania Bowers, legal counsel and head of public policy at APSCo, pointed out that both worker and employer will have to pay the 1.25% rise, for a total of 2.5%. “This will only serve to drive umbrella and PAYE agency worker costs up, which will exacerbate the ongoing shortage of workers that UK employers are currently struggling through.” 

Worse, “in the case of umbrella company workers, most will end up paying both the employers and employees NICs rises so they will be taxed twice”, said Rebecca Seeley Harris, former adviser to the Office of Tax Simplification and chair of the Employment Status Forum.

“This is obviously another blow to workers who are already in a precarious position. This will include care workers and NHS, working in the sector that the levy is supposed to fund, going through umbrellas. More and more are expected to be self-employed or must agree to be employed through agency umbrellas, many of which are unethical. It’s an untenable situation for them,” Seeley said.

James Poyser, CEO of inniAccounts and founder of, added that self-employed professionals would see these latest moves as “yet another cynical indictment by the Conservative government on so-called personal service companies”.

• Comment below on this story. Or let us know what you think by emailing us at [email protected] or tweet us to tell us your thoughts or share this story with a friend.


This week’s new contracts & deals include: Beeken Reeves, Caval, Compono, ettain, GKR London, Greenbean, idibu, ManpowerGroup

Contracts 6 September 2021

FINANCIALS: Empresaria’s profits up, but revenue declines

Global and multi-sector recruitment group Empresaria has announced its unaudited interim results for the six months ended 30 June 2021.

Financials 12 August 2021

HMRC slaps tax fine on Home Office for wrong IR35 assessments

HM Revenue & Customs has been busy dishing out penalties for unpaid tax due to wrong off-payroll workers’ status.

Legislation 30 July 2021

House of HR firm Cohedron acquires Vanberkel Professionals

House of HR’s Dutch service provider Cohedron is to acquire consultancy firm Vanberkel Professionals.

Contracts 29 July 2021